Man must want and even need to obey, instead of only fearing to disobey. The slave owner, on the other hand, wants to exploit the slave as much as possible. Keating who throws off the balance by going against this time honored way of teaching. I completely agree with E. January 21, 2009 — Fromm begins his essay discussing how human kind emerged because of disobedience. Assuming that addictions became a primary focus on a person life it can highly affect their well-being and be fairly harmful to the person.
They are the problems of how to be loved, the object to love as well as the confusion between the initial experience of falling in love and the permanent state of being in love, which had a great impact on me, as far as thinking…. As long as I am obedient to the power of the State, the Church, or public opinion, I feel safe and protected. Furthermore, throughout the bible we see Jesus consistently defying the law of Israel to free the people of Israel from the pharisaic law Garrett Luke 23:1,23:24. Fromm argues that if disobedience began history, then obedience will end it. Milena Nikolovska Nikolovska 1 Summary Erich Fromm is a distinguished German writer, who has large interests in psychology, philosophy, sociology and history. One must have the self-confidence and assurance within himself to be independent from Authority and stand alone against the Group. .
The Moral Dilemma of Obeying AuthorityCivil disobedience has become a pandemic in todays society. If a human being is open to criticisms and takes any… 1214 Words 5 Pages Few Good Men was a critically acclaimed movie and was nominated for multiple Academy Awards. Likewise Martin Luther king Jr. Therefore, Fromm proclaims that without disobedience the human race could destroy itself within a generation. Almost all of these statements go against standard religious beliefs which could pose a threat to a clear reading of his article by a religious audience.
Humans were in harmony with nature, yet still in their infancy. King further characterizes the white moderate as lacking a moral compass in the institution of the white church. There are no facts to back up the thought that humans may destroy the world, especially in a specified time frame. Twelve Greeks and Romand Who Changed The World. Using this correlation, Fromm shows freedom as a condition for disobedience, and vice- versa.
In this paper I will identify two different cultures in the world which are the American and Japanese. Civil disobedience in its purest form is a particularly strong concept because it requires a self-purification process. The last appeal he uses is ethos or authors credibility. The organization man has lost the capacity to disobey, he is not even aware of the fact that he obeys. A small child does not naturally stand against its family. Is Disobedience a Psychological and Moral Problem? The fact that the type of hair cream, the car we drive, our partners we chose, even the toilet paper that we flush down the toilet reflects the needs of our friends, and it keeps us chained to the false sense of security and obedience.
It is a collection of four previously published. What he fails to mention is that statistics gathering has become far more accurate in recent years. Headings will help the reader stay organized when reviewing your article. I couldn't take any pictures in the museum due to the many signs up saying not to, The exhibit that is on permanent display is The Lonesome Dove Collection. It is because of these claims I have to partially disagree with the general idea with his essay.
In history, however, civil disobedience has played an enormous role in the evolution of society. While discussing the positions of disobedience being considered a vice, and obedience being a virtue, Fromm reflects upon the history of Adam and Eve believing… 1286 Words 6 Pages the Tutsis as schemers and assassins to prevent personal injury to themselves and their loved ones. Since Fromm was a psychoanalyst, sociologist, historian and philosopher, also a widely published author, and studied the works of Freud and Marx, one would be lead to believe that he is a highly credible source. Adolf Eichmann, who was responsible for many deaths, stated after being captured that he was only following orders. These two ideas are completely too far apart on the scale to even try to compare to each other. Fromm explains that if mankind commits suicide it will be because individuals will be blindly obeying commands of those in leadership all in the name of the states honor.
A person can become free through acts of disobedience by learning to say no to power. During a public action of civil disobedience such as protest, one must be sure to always announce the reason and purpose behind his or her disobedience. Besides religion, looking at the world sociopolitical arena we see that due to various acts of disobedience by a handful enabled many people to enjoy freedom. He states that we would and that we do in the same situation. Additionally, looking at this from the religious aspect we see that throughout the bible it was due to disobedience man started to become free. The production of the farm was affected and the produces were lower.