Cs lewis and sigmund freud. The Question of God: Sigmund Freud & C.S. Lewis (2004) Movie Reviews & Ratings 2019-01-03

Cs lewis and sigmund freud Rating: 7,4/10 1158 reviews

Freud, C. S. Lewis, and the Question of God

cs lewis and sigmund freud

The book deals with all the great questions: God, morality, pain, sex, and death. He became a prolific author, selling millions of copies of books and influencing many people in universities, especially in this country and in Europe. A good premise, but a flawed execution. Unlike Freud, Lewis is still viewed as a standard — of Christian apologetics. He should have written more Narnia books. Lewis might respond, using an extract from Lewis' The Silver Chair.


Next

C.S. Lewis and Sigmund Freud: Independent Institute

cs lewis and sigmund freud

The author is clearly a spiritualist as opposed to a materialist. After reading the book, Freud reminded his physician of a promise he had made to help ease his passing when the time came. What materialist turns to Freud for guidance these days? ” They talked and walked for hours along a path called Addison’s Walk. It influences how we perceive ourselves, how we relate to others, how we adjust to adversity, and what we understand to be our purpose. Lewis and Sigmund Freud, two remarkable men with sharply divergent worldviews. ” He later said that Phister was, “In the fortunate position of being able to lead men to God.

Next

The Question of God . Why Freud & Lewis?

cs lewis and sigmund freud

The other views death as the final step in the design for one’s life, a step that one can experience with a degree of calmness and even anticipation because of what Lewis called “that grand miracle,” the resurrection. Nicholi wants it both ways and will take either when it is convenient to his perspective. Of course, Lewis was himself for much of his early adult life an atheist before he began his spiritual journey under the influence of men like J. Chesterton’s and finally arrived at a belief in God. You see, how we learn about religion or come to any belief for that matter, is a separate question from whether or not it is true.

Next

Freud, C. S. Lewis, and the Question of God

cs lewis and sigmund freud

Even where what is in question is not inanimate nature, but where an individual’s fate depends on his relationships with other people, it is by no means the rule that virtue is rewarded and evil finds its punishment. This book paints a general picture of each man, of their lives and of what they believed. But it's not actually a book: it's a very clever string of quotes from the writings of Freud and Lewis. On November 22, 1963, Lewis’s brother brought Lewis his 4 p. And yet, I am compelled to somewhat agree with this, though not quite full-heartily.

Next

The Question of God: Sigmund Freud & C.S. Lewis (TV Movie 2004)

cs lewis and sigmund freud

Fue muy entretenido y muy revelador el poder ver los mismos tópicos vistos desde puntos de vistas casi opuestos. And the director, Tyler Marchant, maintained a taut, well-paced tension, negotiating a conversational conflict and finding all the drama possible in the encounter between young man and old man, healthy man and dying man, Christian and Jew, focusing on their fascination with each other. Logical when you think about it. Even the idea of a meme could be the result of a meme and so it really is a fruitless concept. In this instance, Lewis is referencing the desire to see people free from irrational fears. It has some other cause — the influence of parents or the need for an emotional crutch or a female mentality.

Next

The Question of God . Why Freud & Lewis?

cs lewis and sigmund freud

Well, I guess I wouldn't say to avoid it. Then re-reading Euripides and Samuel Alexander’s , Lewis was forced to think about a deep yearning in himself; he recognized that it was a kind of yearning he experienced periodically but did not quite understand. He recovered, however, and lived the next few months quietly and happily. He recalled that his “whole existence changed into something alien and menacing, as the house became full of strange smells and midnight noises and sinister whispered conversations. Throughout the ages, many of the world's greatest thinkers have wrestled with the concept of -- and belief in -- God. I found it interesting to read about the personal lives of both of these giants of the 20th century. I would also recommend it to anyone who has struggled with this debate themselves i.

Next

Freud, C. S. Lewis, and the Question of God

cs lewis and sigmund freud

I would also recommend it to anyone who has struggled with this debate themselves i. One thing is clear: Lewis was happy. Lewis on 'Bulverism' But long before Narnia, Lewis wrote an essay to expose the shear hopelessness of this way of arguing — he called it 'Bulverism'. Critical readers who are appropriately resentful to such deception will leave this book feeling bitter and betrayed. The second is, does the taint invalidate the tainted thought — in the sense of making it untrue — or not? I don’t think I’ve ever experienced such grief.

Next

Question of Sigmund Freud And C.S. Lewis

cs lewis and sigmund freud

Freud and Lewis were both well-versed in the Bible. Nicholi employs a modern arsenal of psychology, genetics, neuroscience, and even generally erroneous Gallup polls to contradict Freud, but not Lewis. He realized that this joy was not an end in itself, but a reminder of something or someone else. He admired Phister and wrote, “You are a true servant of God. They never had an actual m Throughout the ages, many of the world's greatest thinkers have wrestled with the concept of -- and belief in -- God. Its clear from reading this book why one chose to believe in God and the other saw it as a form of neurosis. The latter could still smoke his pipe, but from the other end.

Next

Freud's Dad & Dawkins' Delusion

cs lewis and sigmund freud

Fans of Freud have complained about the book because they think that Lewis comes out of these debates much stronger than Freud. It was for sure worth the read; I learned a lot, and I went through different emotions as I read it and thought both about the material in the book and how the ideas fit into my life. Lots of biographical material is included as well. Am I a Christian because I picked up a religious virus from someone at school? Lewis deals with this objection both by way of imagination by looking at an episode in the Narnia stories, The Silver Chair, and then by way of argumentation in an essay he wrote back in 1941. He directly accuses Lewis of that vice at one point.

Next